1 in 3 activities labeled green in EU Taxonomy are bad for the planet, new alternative Taxonomy shows
Independent Science-Based Taxonomy launched to save EU’s official list of green investments
Today, the Observatory Against Greenwashing, a coalition of experts and NGOs, launches its Independent Science-Based Taxonomy. Banks, investors and insurers will be able to check if their investments are truly green and aligned with science on the website www.greenwashed.net.
The initiative aims to bring clarity to investors after the EU labelled gas-fired power, nuclear, the burning of trees, intensive logging, and other harmful activities as “sustainable” in the EU Taxonomy – the new European “green” investment guidebook. The controversial Taxonomy Act on gas-fired power and nuclear entered into force on 1st January 2023.
Luca Bonaccorsi, sustainable finance director at T&E, said: “The EU Taxonomy was originally designed to fight greenwashing but instead has become another tool to deceive consumers. One out of every three activities the EU has labelled green, is harmful to the planet. This isn’t good enough. We need a better taxonomy, one based on science. Now the investor community has it.”
The Independent Science-Based Taxonomy duplicates the EU Taxonomy’s criteria wherever they are robust and only departs from them when they are not rooted in science or harmful to the environment.
A spokesperson for the Observatory Against Greenwashing added: “This is only a first step. In the future, the Independent Science-Based Taxonomy will also provide more criteria to help the market anticipate future updates of the Taxonomy and connect the Taxonomy with available sector-specific 2050 decarbonisation pathways and contributions to biodiversity, pollution prevention, water protection and circular economy.“
The Independent Science-Based Taxonomy will gradually extend the Taxonomy framework rather than focusing on the currently small proportion of sectors deemed ‘sustainable’. It will categorise all economic activities using a traffic light system: green for sustainable activities, amber for activities that operate between significantly harmful and substantial contribution performance levels, and red for harmful activities. Furthermore, the criteria to categorise the economic activities will be updated every 3 to 5 years to reflect technological, scientific and legislative developments.
The first version of the Independent Science-Based Taxonomy relies on a preliminary assessment of the EU Taxonomy by a Technical Expert Group. However, the TEG will continue to carry out further technical analysis in order to refine the criteria for a science-based Taxonomy. The Secretariat of the Independent Science-Based Taxonomy is inviting qualified candidates to apply to our Call for Experts to serve as Members of the Technical Expert Group of the Independent Science-Based Taxonomy from Wednesday 18 January 2023.
